One of the most difficult divorces one can encounter is with deep religious beliefs, especially within Christian and Catholic communities where marriage is seen as a lifelong commitment. For many people in these communities, the doctrine that marriage is forever makes the prospect of divorce incredibly challenging. I have spoken to individuals in this situation who find it extremely difficult to navigate the doctrinal teachings of their faith.
I'd like to mention that there is significant importance in addressing this issue, as people need to find a way out of unhappy or unhealthy marriages. Fortunately, there are resources available. One such resource is an article titled "The Catholic Church, Marriage, and Annulment," written by Rev. Jeffrey Keefe, OFM Conv.
Rev. Keefe's article provides a detailed explanation of the basis for annulment within the Catholic Church. One of the key points he addresses is the capacity to consent and fully understand the covenant of marriage. He explains that individuals with mental illness or personality disorders lack the capacity to uphold the commitments of marriage. For the spouse married to a person with a personality disorder, it can be an unbearable situation that the Church recognizes as a valid reason for annulment.
The rest of this blog will primarily be excerpts from Rev. Keefe's article, as it is incredibly well-written and provides valuable insights. I feel incredibly fortunate to have found this article, and I believe it deserves to be shared among those who are healthy spouses on the verge of divorcing a partner with a personality disorder and are encountering tremendous backlash in their communities. This article is extremely humane and offers much-needed support and understanding for those in such difficult circumstances.
By spreading this information, we can help individuals who are struggling to reconcile their faith with the reality of their marital situation. Rev. Keefe's work highlights that there is a compassionate and doctrinally sound way for these individuals to seek relief and find peace.
Rev. Jeffrey Keefe explains:
“While carefully protecting Jesus’ teaching of the sacredness of marriage, the Church also is obliged to provide justice for anyone whose marriage has failed when it can be shown with moral certainty that the marriage lacked from its onset some essential element for a true sacramental bond”
The religious and legal precision of the language used in this paragraph is extraordinarily compelling. Essentially, it starts by recognizing the most important element and that is that marriages do fail.
“How can a Church court decide whether a marriage is valid or not? How can anyone undo the ‘I do’?”
This question hits the bull’s-eye. For marriage is effected by consent, freely and knowingly saying “yes” to all that marriage involves. Therefore, in considering a particular marriage, this “yes” is the key issue. Its validity may be considered in the context of two basic questions about consent.
First, when they said their vows, did both partners freely accept and clearly understand the lifelong commitment they were making? And secondly, at that time, did both partners have the personal capacity to carry out consent, to form a community of life with the chosen partner? “
It is simply impossible to add more clarity to this statement by Rev. Jeffrey Keefe. He hits the nail on the head when he says that marriage is valid only if both parties consent freely and knowingly to all aspects of the marriage. The issue of validity arises if either party did not fully understand or willingly accepts the lifelong commitment they were making. This understanding opens the door to a path of salvation and a way out of an abusive marriage.
Rev. Keefe beautifully provides a way forward, emphasizing that this path does not encourage divorce merely for convenience. Instead, he clearly outlines a compassionate and doctrinally sound approach, offering hope and a solution for those trapped in abusive relationships while upholding the sanctity of marriage.
“What type of emotional problems could impair the consent?”
“...Another group of emotional disturbances carry the label personality disorders. The personality disorders do not show the acute episodes or bizarre features of psychoses, or the disabling anxiety or symptoms of neuroses. However, they are marked by deeply ingrained maladaptive patterns of behavior, usually with roots in early life, and often evident by adolescence.”
Personality disorders are a category of mental health issues that don’t display the dramatic symptoms seen in severe conditions like psychosis or intense anxiety disorders. For instance, people with psychosis might have hallucinations or delusions, and those with severe anxiety might have panic attacks. Instead, personality disorders involve ongoing, harmful ways of thinking and behaving that start early in life, often becoming noticeable during the teenage years. These behaviors are deeply rooted and consistent, such as difficulty in managing emotions, forming stable relationships, or behaving appropriately in social situations. These patterns are not just occasional but are consistent traits that negatively impact a person’s life and those around them.
“The facts garnered from a personal history may reveal that an individual carried a tremendous resentment which sabotaged the marital relationship by constant and uncontrolled temper outbursts, by demanding and depreciating attacks on the spouse and children, and even by physical abuse. “
When looking into someone’s background, it might become clear that they have harbored deep-seated anger and resentment. This built-up negativity can cause significant problems in a marriage. For example, the person might frequently lose their temper in uncontrollable outbursts, making home life stressful and unpredictable. They might constantly criticize and demean their spouse and children, undermining their confidence and well-being. In more severe cases, this anger can escalate to physical abuse, causing harm and creating a dangerous environment. These behaviors can destroy trust and safety in a relationship, making it impossible for the marriage to be healthy and supportive.
Catholic Annulment
“.... Marriage to someone with a severe personality disorder is at best, cohabitation, at worst a living hell. A relationship of constant discord, tension and debilitating stress is hardly a community of life and love.“
Living with someone who has a severe personality disorder is extremely challenging. At best, it might feel like merely living together without any real connection or partnership. At worst, it can be like living in a nightmare, with constant arguments, tension, and overwhelming stress. This kind of relationship lacks the mutual support, love, and harmony that a healthy marriage should have. Instead of being a source of comfort and stability, the marriage becomes a source of anxiety and conflict, making it a difficult and painful experience for everyone involved. This environment is far from the loving, supportive community that marriage is intended to be.
Conclusion
Navigating a divorce within deeply religious communities, particularly those with strong Christian and Catholic beliefs presents unique challenges. The doctrine that marriage is a lifelong commitment makes the prospect of divorce daunting and complex. However, resources like Rev. Jeffrey Keefe's article "The Catholic Church, Marriage, and Annulment" offer valuable insights and hope for those in such difficult situations.
Rev. Keefe highlights the critical importance of genuine consent in marriage. He explains that for a marriage to be valid, both parties must fully understand and freely accept the lifelong commitment they are making. This understanding is crucial, especially when dealing with cases involving mental illness or personality disorders, which can impair a person's ability to consent. The Church acknowledges these conditions as valid grounds for annulment, providing a compassionate path for individuals trapped in abusive or unhealthy marriages.
Rev. Keefe's work emphasizes that seeking an annulment is not about encouraging divorce for convenience but about recognizing and addressing situations where a true marital bond can never be fully established. His approach offers a way forward for those struggling to reconcile their faith with the reality of divorce, providing a doctrinally sound and humane solution. As he calls it a “declaration of nulity”
Understanding the dynamics of personality disorders is crucial in these cases. Such disorders involve deeply ingrained, maladaptive behaviors that start early in life and become evident in adolescence.
By spreading this information, we can help individuals in religious communities understand that there is a compassionate and just way to address the challenges of an unhealthy marriage. Rev. Keefe's insights offer hope and a way forward, ensuring that the sanctity of marriage is upheld while also providing justice and relief for those in need.
Comments